Cambodia Investment Review

The Blue Circle $140M pilot wind project uncertain as stalemate continues with EdC

The Blue Circle $140M pilot wind project uncertain as stalemate continues with EdC

The future of wind energy firm The Blue Circle 80MW pilot project in Cambodia’s southern Kampot province remains uncertain as a stalemate continues regarding its Power Purchase Agreement (PPA) with Electricite du Cambodge (EdC).

A deal was expected to be signed between the French-owned firm and the State-run electricity utility in the second half of last year however price disputes and now uncertain power usage attributed to the COVID 19 impact on industry seems to have put the entire project on hold.

The Blue Circle planned to build at least 10 wind turbines with 80MW total capacity on top of Bokor mountain in Teuk Chhou district’s Koh Touch commune.

The cost of investing in wind energy was estimated between $1.5-$2 million per megawatt, meaning the pilot project was expected to bring an investment of around $140 million.

The Blue Circle has proposed a PPA price of $0.688 per kWh, a price which has been so far rejected by EdC.

Amaury Brucker, spokesperson for The Blue Circle told Cambodia Investment Review that the company remains in discussion for its proposed Power Purchase Agreement (PPA) terms .

“The current pandemic situation makes the visibility on energy demand quite low which has lengthened the negotiation process with EdC. We maintain that our proposed PPA price of $0.688 per kWh is already the lowest price for wind energy in Southeast Asia,” Brucker said.

“It is also consistent with the latest solar PPA price signed by EdC at $0.76 per kWh and lower than the cheapest PPA price signed for a coal power plant in Cambodia at $0.743 kWh,” he added.

Bridget McIntosh, Country of Director of EnergyLab told Cambodia Investment Review that the current price offered was highly competitive, adding, the project is great for EdC as it’s much closer to transmission lines, comparing to say the cost to transmit the new coal power imports from Laos

“It’s certainly lower than EDCs latest agreement of $0.079 per kWh for the upper Tatay hydro power; and significantly lower than the current wind projects in Vietnam at $0.085 per kWh,” McIntosh said.

“But it’s not all about price – the economic, energy security and grid complimentary benefits of wind power all add up to a better outcome for Cambodia,” she added.

Industry insiders have raised further doubts over the project saying it’s a very hard sell at the moment as EdC currently prefers solar over wind because there is already an oversupply of power at night and in the wet season. 

Coal power contracts have 80% take or pay clauses, which means EDC has to pay even if they don’t use the power. Wind projects produce roughly 50:50 day and night; 50% wet and dry season, which is actually helpful to incorporate more solar, they said.

Keo Rattanak, Director-General of EdC agreed that technically and financially the Ministry is leaning towards more solar. Adding, however it was not simply an EdC decisions to make as Finance and Energy ministries are big decision makers on this size.

“It would be the collective decision of MEF, MME, EAC and EDC,” he said.

Energy Minister Suy Sem has previously said the ministry’s number one priority is the development of electricity sources to improve production capacity, transmission, distribution and connection.

He added that the Ministry has been working to ensure that the Kingdom’s electricity supply remained stable and meets growing demand.

Cambodia has included in its 2030 Electricity Master Plan 1,800MW of solar, with only 80MW of wind energy by 2024.

Related Articles